Larry Lowenthal, Executive Director of the Boston chapter of the AJC (American Jewish Committee), writes in the Jewish Advocate about Judge Roberts nomination:
Jews, like all other Americans, have studied the reports on
John Roberts, President Bush’s impeccably credentialed, but personally
enigmatic nominee to the U.S. Supreme Court.
We learn that he is “charming, modest, and outgoing;” a man
of “integrity,” with an “even temper” and a “respectful demeanor;” that he is possessed
of a “great sense of humor”; able to draw a rapport with most people he meets;
a man who “makes everyone comfortable”; a very “affable” man, a “nice” man, a
brilliant legal scholar and an astonishingly thorough litigator.
But Jews worry that Roberts’ endearing style may not reflect
his substantive positions. We know that he is fundamentally a conservative, but
his personal attitudes toward issues of specific concern to the Jewish
community—abortion, gay rights, affirmative action, civil liberties,
church-state separation, environmental protection, gun control, gender equality,
and freedom from unreasonable government actions--remain ambiguous or hidden.
Jews—like all Americans—face a tantalizing question: is John
Roberts simply a respected jurist with an apparently unblemished legal career,
or is he an ideological partisan who will radically alter our way of life for
decades to come? [Download larry_lowenthal_open_ed_in_ja.doc
]
Larry's op-ed raised quite a few eyebrows in the Jewish Russian community of Boston.
Here is what Alex Koifman, Board Member of the Boston chapter of AJC, had to say on the topic in his public letter to Larry Lowenthal:
Hi Larry,
You wrote:
...his (Roberts') personal attitudes toward issues of specific concern to
the Jewish community-abortion, gay rights, affirmative action, civil
liberties, church-state separation, environmental protection, gun control,
gender equality, and freedom from unreasonable government actions--remain
ambiguous or hidden.
Since when are these specific concerns to the Jewish Community? These are the Left's concerns. Therefore, it should be stated so. I would not mind if we associated ourselves with the Left, but unfortunately it is hard for some of us, because the Left today are the biggest anti-Israel bigots.
As a political organization we should be building bridges. What bridges are we building here? Not even to minorities, because they are not for gay rights and abortions. When was the last time gays paraded for Israel?
Minorities? The Left is parading against Israel with absolute disregard of the Jewish "concerns". Look what is happening with divestment efforts at home - in Somerville and Harvard/MIT.
On the other hand we are alienating our biggest allies - Conservatives.
Are we in a lose-lose situation here? And I do not just mean this because
Roberts will get confirmed.
Sincerely,
Alex Koifman, AJC Board Member
Good for you, Alex. We are getting sick and tired of being fed by the Jewish Establishment talking points distributed by the Democratic party operatives. How about Republican ones for a change.
Here is an email we recieved from Ken Mehlman, RNC Chairman:
Judge Roberts is a fair-minded
and compassionate jurist. He has
received the highest rating from the American Bar Association and graduated at
the top of his class from Harvard Law School. He has argued before the Supreme Court
39 times, and has been called one of the best Supreme Court lawyers in the
nation. His legal knowledge and
skills are impeccable, and his integrity is unquestionable.
Public reaction to the
President's nomination of Judge Roberts has been overwhelmingly favorable. Recent polls show 59 percent of
Americans think he should be confirmed by the Senate, and prominent Republicans
and Democrats alike have expressed their support for him.
By the way -- Ken Mehlman is Jewish, so is Alex Koifman, so am I, so are about a million of Russian Jews in the US. According to the AJC's own data, 75% of Russian Jews voted for President Bush in 2004. It is time for the American Jewish establishment to kick off their bad habit of adopting leftist positions without much thought and deliberation. This habit is bad for the health of the community.
Background posts on jrtelegraph:
David Harris, Eecutive Director of AJC, meets with the Jewish Russian community of Boston.
Natan Sharansky on voting patterns of Russian Jews.
posted by: Greg (Zvi) Margolin
Recent Comments